Each year, MLB The Show evolves not just as a baseball simulation, but as a nostalgic tribute to the game's greatest players across generations. With its consistently growing Legends roster, fans look forward to MLB The Show 25 Stubs each new installment not just for gameplay improvements or graphical upgrades, but to see which former superstars make the cut. Now, MLB The Show has turned to its community, asking one simple but electrifying question: "Who do you most want to see added to MLB The Show?"
The response has been overwhelming. Fans from every corner of the baseball world—lifelong collectors, Diamond Dynasty grinders, and casual fans alike—have flooded forums and social media with their picks. Some want flashy sluggers, others demand forgotten icons finally get their due. Let's break down some of the most requested legends and why their addition would mean so much to the MLB The Show experience.
1. Ichiro Suzuki
Ichiro might be the most universally requested addition. The Japanese sensation was a masterclass in contact hitting, outfield defense, and throwing accuracy. With a career .311 batting average, over 3,000 MLB hits, and a cannon from right field, Ichiro would be a fan favorite in Diamond Dynasty. His unique stance, smooth swing, and iconic moments like his 2001 AL MVP season make him an ideal candidate for both gameplay variety and historical authenticity.
Ichiro might be the most universally requested addition. The Japanese sensation was a masterclass in contact hitting, outfield defense, and throwing accuracy. With a career .311 batting average, over 3,000 MLB hits, and a cannon from right field, Ichiro would be a fan favorite in Diamond Dynasty. His unique stance, smooth swing, and iconic moments like his 2001 AL MVP season make him an ideal candidate for both gameplay variety and historical authenticity.
Adding Ichiro would also appeal to international fans and bring in a fresh style of play—contact, speed, and defensive precision—which would contrast nicely with the current power-heavy meta.
2. Barry Bonds
The elephant in the room of MLB The Show legend discussions has always been Barry Bonds. The all-time home run king is absent due to licensing complexities, but his name surfaces every year as the most glaring omission. Bonds wasn’t just a power hitter—he was a feared on-base machine with unmatched plate discipline and a cannon of an arm in left field during his prime.
The elephant in the room of MLB The Show legend discussions has always been Barry Bonds. The all-time home run king is absent due to licensing complexities, but his name surfaces every year as the most glaring omission. Bonds wasn’t just a power hitter—he was a feared on-base machine with unmatched plate discipline and a cannon of an arm in left field during his prime.
If ever included, Bonds would instantly become one of the most dominant cards in Diamond Dynasty. Fans dream of a 2001 MVP version with nearly maxed-out hitting stats and ridiculous walk rates. Whether for nostalgia or controversy, adding Bonds would shake the game’s landscape like few others could.
3. Roger Clemens
Another polarizing, high-demand player is Roger Clemens. With 354 career wins, 7 Cy Young Awards, and an intimidating mound presence, "The Rocket" would instantly become one of the top starting pitchers in the game. His powerful fastball, devastating splitter, and high-intensity persona would translate beautifully into gameplay mechanics.
Another polarizing, high-demand player is Roger Clemens. With 354 career wins, 7 Cy Young Awards, and an intimidating mound presence, "The Rocket" would instantly become one of the top starting pitchers in the game. His powerful fastball, devastating splitter, and high-intensity persona would translate beautifully into gameplay mechanics.
Like Bonds, Clemens’ exclusion has long been speculated to be related to off-the-field issues. But many fans argue that if MLB The Show truly wants to reflect baseball history, including one of the most dominant pitchers ever is a must.
4. Bo Jackson
Bo Jackson isn't just a baseball legend—he’s a cultural icon. The two-sport star captivated audiences with his sheer athleticism, crushing homers and making highlight-reel plays in the outfield. Despite a relatively short MLB career, Jackson's mythos and marketability are enormous.
Bo Jackson isn't just a baseball legend—he’s a cultural icon. The two-sport star captivated audiences with his sheer athleticism, crushing homers and making highlight-reel plays in the outfield. Despite a relatively short MLB career, Jackson's mythos and marketability are enormous.
From a gameplay perspective, Bo would bring unique versatility: high power, elite speed, and one of the best outfield arms of all time. He fits perfectly into The Show's love of high-impact cards, and fans would relish controlling such a dynamic athlete.
5. Josh Gibson
As MLB The Show works to incorporate more Negro League legends—especially after the successful addition of Satchel Paige, Jackie Robinson, and Buck O’Neil—Josh Gibson is at the top of the wishlist. Known as “the Black Babe Ruth,” Gibson is widely regarded as one of the greatest power hitters of all time.
As MLB The Show works to incorporate more Negro League legends—especially after the successful addition of Satchel Paige, Jackie Robinson, and Buck O’Neil—Josh Gibson is at the top of the wishlist. Known as “the Black Babe Ruth,” Gibson is widely regarded as one of the greatest power hitters of all time.
While exact statistics are hard to verify due to incomplete record keeping, historians agree Gibson had legendary raw power. His presence would bring important cultural recognition while offering players an elite catcher card—something that’s always in high demand in Diamond Dynasty.
6. Pedro Martinez
Pedro Martinez had one of the most dominant peaks in MLB history, and fans have been clamoring for his return to The Show. His pinpoint control, nasty changeup, and competitive fire would make him a lethal card in Diamond Dynasty. While he has appeared in previous versions of the game, many want a fully fleshed-out Legend version, complete with multiple variations (1999 MVP Pedro, for example).
Pedro Martinez had one of the most dominant peaks in MLB history, and fans have been clamoring for his return to The Show. His pinpoint control, nasty changeup, and competitive fire would make him a lethal card in Diamond Dynasty. While he has appeared in previous versions of the game, many want a fully fleshed-out Legend version, complete with multiple variations (1999 MVP Pedro, for example).
His reintroduction could also bring fresh animations and pitch tunneling mechanics that mirror his real-life wizardry on the mound.
7. Joe DiMaggio
Despite his legendary 56-game hitting streak and Hall of Fame credentials, Joe DiMaggio has yet to make a proper appearance in MLB The Show. Adding “The Yankee Clipper” would fill a noticeable gap in the game’s representation of baseball’s golden era.
Despite his legendary 56-game hitting streak and Hall of Fame credentials, Joe DiMaggio has yet to make a proper appearance in MLB The Show. Adding “The Yankee Clipper” would fill a noticeable gap in the game’s representation of baseball’s golden era.
With balanced hitting, excellent defense, and historical prestige, DiMaggio would be an exciting card to chase. He’d also round out a more complete New York Yankees All-Time Team, which many Diamond Dynasty players aim to build.
Community Impact
This fan-sourced legend request initiative shows that MLB The Show is actively listening. Whether it’s through Twitter polls, Reddit threads, or YouTube wishlists, this engagement gives players a real stake in the game’s future. It also opens the door for creative ways to introduce new legends—such as themed programs, career spotlight moments, or historical “What If?” scenarios.
This fan-sourced legend request initiative shows that MLB The Show is actively listening. Whether it’s through Twitter polls, Reddit threads, or YouTube wishlists, this engagement gives players a real stake in the game’s future. It also opens the door for creative ways to introduce new legends—such as themed programs, career spotlight moments, or historical “What If?” scenarios.
Final Thoughts
The desire to see legends like Ichiro, Bonds, Gibson, and Bo Jackson added to MLB The Show isn't just about gameplay—it's about legacy, recognition, and honoring baseball's rich, diverse history. These names bring with them not just stats, but stories, culture, and generational memories.
The desire to see legends like Ichiro, Bonds, Gibson, and Bo Jackson added to MLB The Show isn't just about gameplay—it's about legacy, recognition, and honoring baseball's rich, diverse history. These names bring with them not just stats, but stories, culture, and generational memories.
As MLB The Show continues to grow its reach and refine its gameplay, the inclusion of fan-requested legends could cement its role not just as a sports title, but as a living, playable museum of baseball greatness.
Whether you want to launch bombs with Barry, hit lasers with Ichiro, or relive the mythical feats of Bo Jackson, the future of MLB Stubs for sale Legends is in your hands—and your wishlist might just come true.
