MLB The Show 25 offers three main hitting interfaces—Zone, Directional, and Timing—and MLB The Show 25 Stubs each one changes how you approach at-bats. Your choice depends on how much control you want, your skill level, and how much time you’re willing to invest in improving.

1. Zone Hitting (Recommended for Most Players)

How It Works: You control the Plate Coverage Indicator (PCI) with the left stick to match the ball’s location, then swing using your chosen swing type.

Pros:

Maximum control over contact point.

Most accurate and rewarding for skilled players.

Allows you to tailor swings for different pitch locations.

Cons:

Steeper learning curve.

Requires strong hand–eye coordination.

Best For: Players who want competitive consistency, higher averages, and better power potential.

2. Directional Hitting

How It Works: You influence the swing direction (pull, push, or up the middle) with the left stick, while timing your swing. The PCI moves automatically based on ratings.

Pros:

Easier for new players to make solid contact.

Less focus on fine-tuning PCI movement.

Cons:

Less precise than Zone Hitting.

Harder to consistently hit for power or pull specific pitches.

Best For: Casual players or those focusing on franchise or buy MLB Stubs Road to the Show without needing max precision.